Skip to main content

When working on Drupal projects, especially in a collaborative environment, it’s crucial to follow best practices for creating and managing patches. Patches are essential for contributing back to the community, applying quick fixes, or sharing custom changes with your team. In this article, we'll explore the recommended method for creating a Drupal 10 patch and discuss when it might be appropriate to use alternative approaches.

Why patches matter in Drupal development

Patches serve as a way to share modifications to code between different environments or among developers. They’re especially important in the open-source world, where contributions and customizations need to be applied consistently across various installations.

In the context of Drupal, patches are commonly used for:

  • Submitting fixes to contributed modules or themes;
  • Applying customisations that aren’t yet available in the official codebase;
  • Sharing updates within your team before they’re merged into the main branch; and
  • Given their importance, it’s vital to create patches that are accurate, easy to apply, and maintainable over time.

 

The recommended method - using Git

The most robust and scalable method for creating a Drupal 10 patch is by using Git. Git is a powerful version control system that tracks changes in your codebase, making it easier to generate patches that can be applied consistently.

 

Creating a patch with Git

Ensure a clean working directory

Before you start, make sure your working directory is clean. This means committing or stashing any changes you don’t want to include in the patch.

git status

 

Check out the base version

Identify and check out the version of the codebase you’re modifying. This could be a specific branch, tag, or commit that represents the version you’re working from.

git fetch origin
git checkout <branch-or-tag>

 

Create a new branch

It’s a good practice to create a new branch for your changes. This keeps your work isolated and makes it easier to generate a patch later.

git checkout -b my-feature-branch

 

Make your changes

Modify the files as needed. Once you’ve completed your changes, add them to the staging area.

git add .

 

Commit your changes

Commit your changes with a descriptive message that explains what the patch is about.

git commit -m "Fix for issue XYZ: Improved performance of the ABC module"

 

Generate the patch

With your changes committed, you can now create a patch file. This file will contain the differences between the base version and your changes.

git diff <old-branch-or-commit> HEAD > my-patch.patch

Replace <old-branch-or-commit> with the base version you checked out earlier. HEAD refers to your latest commit.

 

Review and share the patch

Before sharing your patch, review its contents to ensure it’s accurate. You can do this by opening the patch file in a text editor.

cat my-patch.patch

Once satisfied, you can share the patch file with others or apply it to another Drupal project using:

git apply my-patch.patch

 

Using Git to create a patch is the preferred approach for several reasons:

  • Version Control: Git tracks changes over time, allowing you to generate patches that accurately reflect the modifications you’ve made;
  • Collaboration: Patches created with Git are easier for others to review and apply, making it the standard practice in open-source projects like Drupal;
  • Consistency: By using Git, you avoid the pitfalls of manual patch creation, such as missing or incorrect changes.

 

When to use alternative methods

There might be scenarios where using Git isn’t practical or necessary. For instance, if you’re dealing with a very simple change in a single file, or if the project isn’t under version control, you might consider manually creating a patch by comparing two versions of the file.

 

Manually creating a patch

If you opt for a manual approach, you would typically have two files: one representing the old version and the other the new version. You can generate a diff between these files using a tool like diff:

diff -u old-file.php new-file.php > my-patch.patch

While this method can work for small, isolated changes, it’s not ideal for larger projects or when working in a team. The lack of version control makes it harder to manage and review the changes.

 

The wrap

In most cases, using Git to create a patch is the best practice, particularly in a professional or collaborative setting. It ensures that your patches are accurate, maintainable, and easy to apply. While alternative methods exist, they are generally less reliable and should be reserved for simpler tasks.